No failure in America, whether of love or money, is ever simple; it is always a kind of betrayal, of a mass of shadowy, shared hopes.
–Greil Marcus, Mystery Train (1975)
I’ve been reading all sorts of stories across the media about people who for whatever reason voted for Trump, cheerleading him on while thinking they themselves would be spared from his rash actions, that punishment would only be meted out to those they felt deserved it. You know– the others.
These same people have discovered in the past 38 or so days that they are not immune from the reckless gutting of America that is taking place. Many have lost jobs that they thought were safe and are left to wonder why. After all, they believed and supported Trump and knew they were honestly doing useful, necessary jobs that supported their families.
They weren’t the problem with America– it was the others.
Or there are stories of the Trump supporting retirees or families who depend on Social Security and Medicare or Medicaid who are realizing that the lifelines that were in place throughout their lifetimes might suddenly be dramatically slashed or even taken completely away. Or that these agencies’ staffs would be cut to the point that they would be able to function properly, if at all.
Then there are the military veterans who in many cases have sacrificed their time and wellbeing to serve this country who are learning that the support that was solemnly promised to them was going to be carved away willy nilly.
There are many other stories like these coming to light from across America. From farmers and private agencies that selflessly help those in need. From small businesspeople and scientists and researchers who have developed the medicines and technologies that have protected and grown this nation.
I’m working off the top of my head here so I am not going to list them all. I couldn’t do that even if I were better prepared. There are too many cases across nearly all fields that are beginning to feel the pain.
All people who thought they would be safe because they knew they weren’t the problem.
It was the others.
And now they feel betrayed and abandoned by the Trump/Musk band of gangsters. And they have been betrayed. As we all have. I have some sympathy for them but could certainly have more had they themselves not been so willing to betray and punish the others, who turned out to be their fellow citizens who, like them, were honestly doing useful work that served this nation. People who most likely share a love of this country, for the better angels so often extolled.
I am not saying that there wasn’t a need for reforms or greater efficiency in our government. Of course there is. But that’s not what we’re witnessing. This is more akin to a hostile corporate takeover where a group of investors– corporate raiders— comes in with little or no interest in running the company. They only want to tear it down and sell it off for parts.
And as it is in such cases, it is the little people who bear the brunt of the damage done. In this case, it those same people who unwittingly voted for this takeover. They betrayed not only the others but themselves and their own self-interest.
And America.
I am sorry to vent this morning. I am trying to stay away from such commentary, if only for my own mental wellbeing. But I am tired of hearing these stories of people surprised that the Grizzly Bear they were feeding suddenly ripped off their arm. There are no stories about those folks who clearly saw this coming for years and years, only to be continually ridiculed and told they were crazy or hyperbolic.
I guess a story about betrayal is far more attractive than an I-told-you-so story. To be honest, there’s not much comfort in either story. Both will feel the effect of this betrayal, along with countries and people around the globe.
Most likely, for a long time to come. Betrayal has a lingering effect.
The quote from journalist Greil Marcus at the top from his wonderful book, Mystery Train, on the link between America’s growth and that of rock and roll culture set this all off this morning. Here’s the iconic version from Elvis Presley of the song of that same title. The song was written and originally recorded in 1953 by the great Junior Parker.









