Certainty is the dominant addiction of the modern mind.
–Maria Popova, The Marginalian (9/7/26)
I read Maria Popova‘s brilliant blog, The Marginalian, on a regular basis. The short sentence above in a post from a couple of months back hit the nail on the head for what I have been thinking for some time, that certainty is the cause of so much conflict and discontent in the world. Our absolute certainty reduces every issue down to the point where there is only a binary choice to be made: one that is right and one that is wrong.
My certainty is absolute and correct so any uncertainty that you find in it must be wrong.
You can see the conflict already brewing in that single sentence.
The world has been reduced to the stark black and white of right and wrong without any space in it for the gray area that is uncertainty.
Has it always been this way? Probably. If you look back through history, certainty was the driving force of the Crusades, the Inquisition, Transatlantic Slave Trade, and just about every war that was waged. If I had more time I could probably come up with more inhumanities that came at the hands of certainty. Manifest Destiny comes to mind.
But is this disease that is certainty worse now? Maybe. It is far easier to now live in an internet and news bubble that feeds and encourages our certainty. We can, with relative anonymity, makes statements that are said with absolute certainty that we would never utter to someone standing in front of us in person.
I should amend that last sentence. In recent times, we have begun to shed our anonymity as our addiction to our certainty has grown. Many of us no longer have even the slightest sense of uncertainty — or shame– in what we believe to be true in our views, even when they seem to defy common sense or common decency. We see our prejudices, biases, and hatreds no longer as mere opinion but as fact without even the slightest consideration as to whether it might be wrong, in either the factual or moral sense.
It’s a recipe for disaster.
In my case, I seldom trust certainty in those rare moments when it begins to enter my mind. I have been wrong far too many times to be positive about anything outside of the occasional Jeopardy question. Or my opinion. I am often certain in my feelings about certain things but understand that this does make it absolutely correct.
Life is, after all, uncertainty.
And that uncertainty is what moves us to question the what-is and search for the what-might-be. It is the driving force behind all change and progress.
We often lose that when certainty enters the room.
I believe the only certainties we should have are in questions of moral behavior. We should be certain that all people are equal, that fairness reigns supreme, and that the idea of love thy neighbor is not mere religious mouthwash that can be spit out when it suits you.
I could go on and on about uncertainty and probably will sometime in the future. But let’s leave it here for this Sunday Morning. Let’s have a song.
This is from a longtime favorite, the late great Stevie Ray Vaughan, the pride and joy of Texas. I was only able to see him perform live once, at a show in 1986 in Utica, NY that was opened by another Texas fave of mine, the Fabulous Thunderbirds whose guitarist was Jimmie Vaughan, Stevie Ray’s older brother. Great show. This is his moody Riviera Paradise from one of his appearances on Austin City Limits. I like his intro to this instrumental: This one goes out to everybody who is still suffering in any way.
Great atmosphere in this song, perfect for a quiet and introspective Sunday morning with a little rain and a lot of grayness outside the studio windows.
