The dumbing down of America is most evident in the slow decay of substantive content in the enormously influential media, the 30-second sound bites (now down to 10 seconds or less), lowest common denominator programming, credulous presentations on pseudoscience and superstition, but especially a kind of celebration of ignorance.
— Carl Sagan, The Demon-Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark (1995)
Every time I read this passage from Carl Sagan and its reference to the 30-second sound bite, my mind instantly pulls up an incident from a number of years ago. Sometime around 2005 or 2006– I can’t recall now– our local newspaper had published an extensive article about me and my work that went over a couple of pages. It was pretty well done, which means it was accurate, something that most articles about me to that time often lacked especially in telling the story of the fall from a ladder that brought me to painting. The reporter did a fine job and it was very complimentary.
It appeared sometime midweek and on Friday night my phone around 6 PM, which was kind of surprising since I seldom get calls from anyone. The person on the phone introduced herself and explained that she was a producer for a show then on CNBC, The Big Idea with Donnie Deutsch. I was baffled as to why she was calling me.
Her first question didn’t help clear up things. She asked if I had been contacted by any of the morning shows such as Good Morning America or The Today Show.
That sent my mind racing as I stood in my driveway in dirty, paint covered clothes. I laughed, not quite understanding why they would be trying to contact me, and told her they had not.
She seemed relieved and explained that the article in my local paper had been the subject of a discussion at their staff meeting that morning. She said the staff liked it but more importantly that Donnie loved the story of a regular guy falling off a ladder which spawns a successful career in art. She then said that they wanted to know if I would be available to appear as part of a panel on the show that was broadcast live the following Monday evening.
What? I was totally flummoxed at that point. The idea that anyone anywhere was talking about that article, let alone wanting me to appear on a national TV show, seemed incomprehensible to me. I said yes, I would be willing to do that. She said they would fly me down on Monday but I said that I would prefer to drive to their studio somewhere around the Palisades in New Jersey. It would be much easier and less time consuming.
She then began to explain the show would work and what would be expected of me. I would be part of a panel of four from a variety of fields. It was sort of pundit panel normally consisting of journalists and authors and scholars and people from the entertainment field.
And possibly me.
She explained that it was rapid-fire, with Donnie peppering the panelists with questions that required short and hopefully substantial answers. She said ideally these answers should be no longer than 20 to 24 seconds. Not even a 30-second sound bite. She asked if could do that.
I said I don’t know and she said that we would play act with her acting as Donnie asking me questions. The next twenty minutes were filled with her throwing me question after question and me responding in way too many words and too much time. She kept urging me to be more succinct, to cut to the core of my answer. I was not used to explaining complex concepts in such short bursts of words. My thoughts tend to wander a bit and saying anything worth hearing usually takes me much longer than 24 seconds.
As this exercise neared the twenty-minute mark with me walking laps up and down my long driveway, I was extremely frustrated. As was the producer as she kept yelling, “Faster, faster!” into my ear.
I finally stopped walking and shouted into the phone, “What the hell do you want me to do? I don’t talk that way!”
“Oooo-kay. I think we’re done here,” was her response. She said they would contact me if they decided to go with me for that show.
Of course, they did not. But as soon as that long oooo-kay came out of the phone, I was totally relieved. While the idea of appearing on national show where I might get some notice for my work seemed appealing initially, that little interview with the show’s producer soured that idea pretty quickly. I knew that I would not have liked myself for trying to fit myself into whatever shape they wanted if I had gone through with it.
I walked back up the drive and told Cheri the story. We both laughed at its absurdity.
Maybe that was my big shot at the big time? Maybe it was a I coulda been a contender moment, like Brando’s character in On the Waterfront.
Maybe. But I think not.
I began watching the pundits on these shows more closely and could see how their answers were always terse and to the point. Well, most of the time. But for many, that way of speaking is an artform in itself.
Just not the kind of artform that works with my way of thinking. But it gave me a story to tell this morning, so I guess it’s worth something.
Here’s song that just came on as I wrote that last sentence. This is Nobody’s Dirty Business from Mississippi John Hurt. I don’t know if it serves as commentary on this post but it felt right in this moment. Good stuff.
The image at the top is an experiment from 1994 that I call Medication. I used it because that was how I imagine my mind was acting during my little interview with the TV lady.
